Let there be absolutely NO doubt: the Criminal Bar Association is fundamentally opposed to the proposed restrictions on the right to jury trials.
In this edition:
Jury Trials
AGFS Fees
Rajiv Menon KC – An Update
The Allegation of Contempt against Rajiv Menon KC – by Andrew Thomas KC
The Court of Appeal intervenes to grant a stay pending appeal
The issue on the appeal
The context of the appeal: the decision in Balogh’s case
The summary prosecution of Rajiv Menon KC
Why this matters: the question of the public interest
Support from the professions: the Garden Court webinar
CBA Position
And Finally…
Please note that there will be no regular Monday Briefings during the August holiday period. The CBA will however be continuing its work on jury trials, the fees consultation, matched funding for pupillage, and other matters, and will be liaising with the Government, the MoJ, the Bar Council, and Circuit Leaders as usual. We will issue news bulletins as necessary.
Jury Trials – A Brief Update
Last week and the week before we wrote of our hope that sense would prevail, and that the new Government administration would publicly recognise that the time has come to abandon the proposals to restrict the right to jury trial.
They have not done so yet.
The new team of Justice Ministers is now in place. We have already congratulated Alex Norris MP on his appointment as Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice. We now welcome Ellie Reeves MP and Andy Slaughter MP, who have been appointed Attorney General and Solicitor General respectively. Also:
Catherine McKinnell MP, Minister of State for Prisons, Probation, and Reducing Reoffending;
Lord Lemos, taking the role previously held by Baroness Levitt KC, as Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Justice;
Alex Davies-Jones as Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Victims and Tackling Violence against Women and Girls; and
Jake Richards, now Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Sentencing, Youth Justice, and International.
Sarah Sackman MP has retained her position as Minister for Courts and Legal Services. We congratulate her but, as she knows, remain resolute in our opposition to Clauses 1 to 7 of the Bill, and in our commitment to the current system of trial by jury. We will not countenance any erosion of that right, nor will we accept the removal of a jury to be replaced by a judge sitting alone, or the potential compromise of a return to Sir Brian Leveson’s original proposals of a judge with two magistrates.
Our new Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s stated policy objectives include “putting the right values and the right standards at the heart of government” and “the care of people at the heart of everything” he and the Government do. The jury system is the epitome of putting people at the centre of the justice system, and the restriction of jury trials is the opposite of everything that Mr Burnham professes to stand for.
We hope that Minister Sackman and those new in office who will now re-review the proposals have listened to all the evidence of the past year. If they have, they will recognise that the proposals are ill-conceived and should be abandoned. We will continue to work collaboratively with them on the other measures that are essential, such as Clauses 8 onwards, which we continue broadly to support, fixing the court infrastructure, maximising efficiency, and reducing delays.
Our work does not stop over the summer. We have a meeting with the MoJ this week and, after a short period to allow those new in post to review and reflect, we will be renewing our campaign with letters, briefing notes, and requests for further engagement in the autumn.
AGFS Fees – A Brief Update
We have convened our Remuneration Committee team and begun the process of conducting a full review of the Government’s proposal for the distribution of the up to £34m (including VAT) towards AGFS fees. A breakdown of the proposals can be found in last week’s Briefing Note here.
Rajiv Menon KC – Update
This past week has been an eventful one in the Contempt proceedings faced by Rajiv Menon KC. We are conscious that there are strongly opposing views within the profession, and that the case has attracted international interest. Some firmly consider that there is a substantive case against this criminal barrister. Some take the view that the proceedings are unfair, and represent a broader attack on freedom of speech, the independent criminal bar, and the integrity of the Criminal Justice System as a whole, and that the case has wider resonance, particularly when considered alongside the proposals to restrict the right to jury trial that are still ongoing.
The CBA is following the case extremely closely. We have been in contact with leading counsel and with the Bar Council. What we have observed, however, is that many who have opined on the rights or wrongs of this matter, and expressed concerns in either direction, have not had the opportunity to read the underlying material, or to follow the proceedings in full.
In entering the debate, it is important to recognise that:
Rajiv Menon KC has denied that he breached the Judge’s ruling, deliberately or at all. This is still an unproven allegation, and he and the others who were involved in the trial, on either side, as our colleagues, deserve our courtesy and respect;
the immediate issue, and the subject of the upcoming appeal, is not whether the Judge’s direction was breached, but is procedural;
the procedural issue relates to whether the summary process, which was initiated in June following the earlier Court of Appeal decision, can be applicable now, many months after the trial has concluded; or
whether the proper course now is to refer the matter to the Attorney General for independent consideration of whether criminal proceedings for contempt should be initiated, including a decision on whether proceedings are in the public interest.
Andrew Thomas KC, Chair Elect of the CBA, has analysed the authorities and rulings in the case, and written the paper below, which clearly summarises the matters in the public domain and the stage the case has reached. We hope this will assist and inform all those who have expressed interest and concern about it.
The Allegation of Contempt against Rajiv Menon KC
- The Court of Appeal has intervened and granted a stay pending appeal
The summary trial of Rajiv Menon KC for alleged contempt of court in his closing speech in the Elbit Systems trial was due to be heard before Mrs Justice Cheema-Grubb this week, on 28th and 29th July 2026.
On Friday 24th July 2026, the Court of Appeal (Males LJ and Cutts J) granted a stay of the trial pending Rajiv Menon’s appeal challenging the jurisdiction of the Court.
The decision can be read here. The appeal itself will now be heard in the autumn.
- The issue on the appeal
The issue on the appeal is whether the Crown Court has jurisdiction to determine the allegation of contempt under the summary process, and/or whether the decision to use the summary process was wrong.
It is argued that the summary process should be used only where it is necessary to take immediate action to protect the integrity of an ongoing case. There is also an issue as to what role, if any, the prosecution may take in such proceedings.
- The context of the appeal: the decision in Balogh’s case
In May 1974, a young solicitor’s clerk named Stephen Balogh became “exceedingly bored” listening to a trial at St Albans Crown Court. He decided to liven up the proceedings by going onto the roof of the courthouse and attempting to release a canister of laughing gas (nitrous oxide) into the air conditioning system. He thought it would be a hilarious practical joke.
Mr Balogh was stupid on many levels. His actions had already drawn suspicion. Waiting police officers nabbed him as soon as he got onto the roof, and before he had a chance to release the gas. To make matters worse, he had ended up over the wrong courtroom. Had he released the gas, the trial which he would have disrupted was one presided over by Mr Justice Melford Stevenson.
The next morning Mr Balogh was brought before the Judge, who did not agree that it was a harmless prank. He dealt with the case summarily as a contempt in the face of the court. He sentenced Mr Balogh to six months’ imprisonment.
Mr Balogh appealed against the finding and challenged whether the Judge had jurisdiction to act summarily. In the Court of Appeal, Lord Denning MR gave a typically concise but erudite ruling, reviewing the law on summary contempt proceedings. He concluded that the Crown Court did indeed have the power to deal summarily with acts which threatened the authority of the court, but that it should be used sparingly.
Lord Denning said:
“This power of summary punishment is a great power, but it is a necessary power. It is given so as to maintain the dignity and authority of the court and to ensure a fair trial. It is to be exercised by the judge of his own motion only when it is urgent and imperative to act immediately, so as to maintain the authority of the court, to prevent disorder, to enable witnesses to be free from fear and jurors from being improperly influenced, and the like. It is, of course, to be exercised with scrupulous care, and only when the case is clear and beyond reasonable doubt…
“As I have said, a judge should act of his own motion only when it is urgent and imperative to act immediately. In all other cases he should not take it upon himself to move. He should leave it to the Attorney General or to the party aggrieved to make a motion in accordance with the rules… The reason is so that he should not appear to be both a prosecutor and judge: for that is a role which does not become him well.”
Stephenson LJ gave a concurring judgment. He concluded that the Judge had been wrong to decide the case summarily. He said:
“This procedure is one to which judges should resort in exceptional circumstances where a contempt is clearly proved and cannot wait to be punished.” Here the facts alleged to constitute contempt were admitted, but there was no need for immediate punishment.
Stephenson LJ said that the necessary conditions for the exercise of the power were that the contempt was clearly proved beyond reasonable doubt, and that it would affect the outcome of proceedings which were “actually proceeding or known to be imminent” unless immediately stopped. He said:
“It must never be invoked unless the ends of justice really require such drastic means… it can only be justified if nothing else will do.”
The case is reported as Balogh v St Albans Crown Court [1974] 3 WLR 314. The Court of Appeal has described the Balogh case as “the leading modern authority on contempt in the face of the court”.
- The summary prosecution of Rajiv Menon KC
The central point in issue on the appeal is the decision of Mr Justice Johnson (the trial judge) to commence summary proceedings instead of referring the matter to the Attorney General to decide whether a prosecution is appropriate and in the public interest.
The first Elbit Systems trial, which is the subject of these proceedings, concluded in January 2026, fully six months ago. Even the re-trial has now concluded; that ended on 5th May 2026. The argument is that the summary process is inappropriate as the proceedings are not “urgent and imperative”.
This is the second set of proceedings against Rajiv Menon KC for what he said in his closing speech. In the original proceedings, the Judge himself referred the case to the Administrative Court with a view to the allegation being determined there.
On 30th April 2026, the Court of Appeal held that the Judge had no jurisdiction to make such a reference “in the absence of an application by the Attorney General”. In other words, it was a novel process unknown to law.
The decision can be read here.
In his decision of 22nd June 2026, Johnson J again declined to refer the matter to the Attorney General, citing delay as the reason not to follow that course. Instead, citing Part 48 of the Criminal Procedure Rules, he referred the case to “a presiding judge” to determine what action to follow. The decision is reported here. A transcript of the relevant parts of Rajiv Menon’s speech is reproduced as an appendix to the judgment.
The case was duly referred to Mr Justice Nicklin, who decided on 29th June 2026 that Rajiv Menon should be summonsed for contempt. That decision is here.
- Why this matters: the question of the public interest
It is not suggested that a barrister is entitled to defy or ignore the rulings of a trial judge. We all know that it is our duty to comply, even if we believe that the Judge has got it wrong.
Criminal practitioners are familiar with the notorious case of R v Farooqi [2013] EWCA Crim 1649, in which Lord Judge LCJ described defence counsel’s closing speech as “misconduct”, “incompetent” and “intolerable”. Although counsel’s conduct in that case was referred to the Attorney General, the decision in the end was to refer the matter to the BSB for disciplinary proceedings. The case firmly establishes that there are limits to what can be said in a closing speech, and that there are consequences for deliberate misconduct.
Rajiv Menon KC denies that he breached Mr Justice Johnson’s rulings, whether intentionally or at all. Should the case proceed, it will be necessary for a Judge to decide whether the speech had in fact been drafted with the intention of staying on the right side of the Judge’s directions.
- Support from the professions: the Garden Court webinar
On 22nd July 2026, Garden Court Chambers, together with Nexus and 1 Pump Court, hosted a webinar to discuss Rajiv Menon’s case. Over 800 people joined to watch the event live. The meeting took place before the Court of Appeal’s decision to stay the hearing pending appeal.
Chaired by Pete Weatherby KC of Garden Court North, the meeting heard contributions from speakers including Baroness Chakrabarti, Lord Hendy KC, Riel Karmy-Jones KC (Chair of the CBA), Michael Mansfield KC, Keir Monteith KC, Gareth Peirce, Sarah-Jane Ewart, Raju Bhatt, Matt Ford (of the charity APPEAL) and from Rajiv Menon KC himself.
The Guardian’s report of the meeting can be read here.
A full recording can be seen here.
- The CBA Position
The CBA has been made aware of cases where barristers have become uncertain of what they can and cannot say in their speeches in court, and fearful that they themselves might, at the end of a trial, be facing a criminal charge of contempt, even when no direction has been made. This has been said to affect their ability properly to represent their clients.
We have expressed concern about the use of the summary procedure in this case, and the decision not to refer the case to the Attorney General for review. Judges of the Crown Court do not normally decide whether a criminal prosecution is in the public interest. To do so risks undermining their role as independent arbiters of the case. In the case of contempt proceedings, it is normally the Attorney General who investigates the case, determines whether there is sufficient evidence to charge and, crucially, whether proceedings are in the public interest.
And Finally…
To those of you heading off for the summer, have a wonderful holiday. We hope that you can enjoy some proper time away from work doing what you enjoy most.
To those of you who will continue to work across the summer, thank you for keeping our courts running.
We hope you can keep cool, and that you get your break soon.
Yours,
Riel Karmy‑Jones KC Andrew Thomas KC
Chair Vice‑Chair
