Skip to content
The Criminal Bar Association

News

CBA response to announcement on Courts and Tribunals Bill

CBA Press ReleaseSunday 4th October 2026

Andrew Thomas KC, Chair of the Criminal Bar Association, said:

“We are delighted that Andy Burnham’s government has scrapped plans for judge-only trials. Justice needs juries. Nothing inspires more public trust than 12 ordinary citizens from all walks of life deciding the facts of a case together.

Trial by jury is the gold standard of fairness, and we thank the Lord Chancellor and Justice Ministers for listening to the evidence and reaching the right verdict. We are grateful also to the many MPs of all parties who have taken the time to meet with us and to visit our Courts to see first hand the fantastic work which they do.

We are also pleased that the Government is going ahead with important changes in the Bill to protect victims and witnesses at trial. These include new powers to prevent unfair questioning about a complainant’s behaviour and to support witnesses to give their best evidence.

Yet, a severe threat to our trial by jury remains in the Bill. The proposal to strip defendants of their right to elect a Crown Court trial, combined with doubling Magistrates' sentencing powers to two years, would shift 25,000 cases a year (including 5,500 jury trials) out of the Crown Court.

These are not minor offences. It includes serious and sensitive cases including assaults, sexual assaults, child abuse and GBH. Our volunteer Magistrates do an excellent job but they are completely unequipped to try complex, multi-day trials. What makes it worse is that it is far more difficult to get Legal Aid in the Magistrates' Courts, and people facing long sentences of imprisonment will end up representing themselves.

The Magistrates’ Courts simply cannot cope. Since this proposal was first announced, the Crown Court backlog has stabilised but the backlog of open court case in the Magistrates' Courts has surged by 16% annually, and up to 40% in some regions.

They do not have enough Magistrates, enough qualified legal advisers or enough resources to take on thousands of more sensitive cases. It would be a car crash if they tried to do it, especially at this time.”

Ends

NOTES:

The Impact of the Changes

The Government’s Impact Assessment on the Courts and Tribunals Bill states [at page 16] that the combined effect of removing the right to elect Crown Court trial and the increase in Magistrates’ Sentencing powers would be to retain 25,000 cases pa in the Magistrates’ Court, including 5,500 trials.

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/bills/cbill/59-01/0389/IRCC_impact_assessment.pdf

The CBA has criticised the Impact Assessment as hopelessly unrealistic, because it claims [at page 17] that this change would reduce the work of the Crown Court by 24,000 sitting days per annum, but add only 8,500 sitting days to the Magistrates’ Court. In other words, it is suggesting that volunteer Magistrates would be able to deal with the work nearly three times faster than the professional Circuit Judges who sit in the Crown Court.

The discrepancy arises because the Impact Assessment fails to take account of the more serious, more complex nature of the 25,000 cases which are within scope of the change. It is not like-for-like with the simple cases which Magistrates Court are currently able to process at speed. For example, most of the trials which would fall within scope would be multi-day trials. Many of them require sensitive legal rulings, such as on the admissibility of evidence of previous convictions and hearsay evidence, or on the questioning of complainants in cases involving sexual offences and domestic abuse.

The Capacity of the Magistrates Court

The majority of the work in the Magistrates’ Court is undertaken by unpaid volunteer Magistrates. In the latest Judicial figures, there were 15,259 magistrates in post (compared to approximately 30,000 in 2006). There are also 129 professional District Judges, and a smaller number of deputies.

Magistrates’ Court work is divided into two procedures:

1.The Single Justice Procedure (SJP) which deals with straightforward, non-imprisonable cases such as speeding offences, watching TV without a licence and fare evasion where a guilty plea has been entered by post. These cases are processed by a single Magistrate ‘on the papers’. In practice, it means that a Magistrate will sit at a computer to process the cases and determine the amount of a fine to be paid.

2.The Open Court procedure which deals with cases where there could be a sentence of imprisonment or community punishment and with all trials. These cases are dealt with either by a professional District Judge or by a bench of 3 magistrates, including at least one experienced magistrate who has been trained to act as Chair. They also sit with a qualified legal adviser.

In the latest Criminal Courts Statistics (to 30th June 2026) the overall backlog of cases in the Magistrates’ Court was 380,230 cases, reflecting an annual increase of 9.5%.

However, that is the combined figure for Open Court cases and the more straightforward SJP cases.

For SJP cases, the backlog is 184,241 cases: an annual increase of 3.3%,

For Open Court cases, the backlog is 195,969 cases: an annual increase of 16%.

Some regions are performing worse than others. Central London and South London both saw increases in excess of 40%. Merseyside increased by 25% and Cheshire by 40%. In Wales the increase was 27%.

The Justice Select Committee Report

Although the Government has ambitious plans to recruit and train more volunteer Magistrates, they are in the early stages still.

The Justice Select Committee, chaired by Andy Slaughter MP (now Solicitor General) considered the issue of capacity in its hearings on the Courts and Tribunals Bill. The Committee’s report concluded as follows:

https://committees.parliament.uk/publications/53510/documents/298926/default/

Conclusion 30

“Clause 6 is one of the most radical measures proposed in the bill. It would give the power to the government to double the sentencing powers of magistrates from the current maximum of 12 months to 24 months through a statutory instrument with limited parliamentary oversight.

The government has presented this as a moderate measure which simply modifies an existing power. However, there are good reasons to question this. In Part 1 of the IRCC, Sir Brian recommended removing the power to vary the maximum sentencing power of the magistrates’ court and permanently setting it at 12 months. Clause 6 is diametrically opposed to what Sir Brian recommended.

Enabling lay magistrates to impose a custodial sentence of 24 months represents a significant shift in criminal justice policy, and we are not convinced that this has been sufficiently justified.

Doubling the maximum custodial sentence will lead to more serious and complex cases being tried in the magistrates’ courts, and this will further increase workload pressures on a court which is already experiencing capacity issues.”

Conclusion 42

“We are not convinced that the capacity of the magistrates’ court can be expanded sufficiently to deal with the potential increases in workload that could result from the changes in the bill. It seems unrealistic to propose that 7,000 magistrates can be recruited in three years and that there will be 21,000 magistrates by 2029. The decline in the number of magistrates and legal advisers is part of a long-term trend which we do not believe can be reversed simply because the government has decided that allocating more cases to the magistrates’ court is the preferred solution to the crisis in the Crown Court.”