Skip to content
The Criminal Bar Association

News

The CBA Briefing: 21st September 2026

The CBA Briefing21st September 2026

The Government backs specialist rape courts, the Courts and Tribunals Bill returns on 13th October, and the Listing Framework takes effect on 1st October.

The CBA Briefing

21st September 2026

Let there be absolutely no doubt: the Criminal Bar Association is fundamentally opposed to the proposed restrictions on the right to jury trial.

In this edition

•

Courts and Tribunals Bill: an update

•

Government supports specialist rape courts

•

Will Judge-only trials remain in the Bill?

•

National Listing Framework

Courts and Tribunals Bill: an update

The Courts and Tribunals Bill is scheduled to return to the Commons for its Third Reading on 13th October 2026, the second day back after the Parliamentary recess. The Government itself is expected to make substantial amendments to the Bill, but we do not yet know for sure what those will be.

In July, the Prime Minister, Andy Burnham MP, announced a review of the Bill’s contents. He said: “My instincts are that we need to find ways of not reducing access to jury trials.” He said that he wanted to look into the details of the Bill himself: “I want to get inside these issues before I confirm any of the plans that I inherited and, in fact, probably looking for changes.”

Much of what has been reported in recent days is speculation about the scope of changes to the Bill, and we must reserve judgment until we know precisely what its final shape will be.

Government supports specialist rape courts

The first confirmed change was announced last night, Sunday 20th September. The Government has announced its support for the rollout of specialist courtrooms for rape and sexual offences throughout the Crown Court system. It has been reported by the Daily Mail and Sky News.

This was a proposal for which the CBA has been campaigning, together with the Bar Council, victim support groups and many MPs. It was a commitment in the 2024 Labour manifesto but was not included in the package of reforms announced with the Bill by the former Secretary of State for Justice, David Lammy MP.

Taken together with the changes in the National Listing Framework, discussed below, this will mean that priority can be given to the listing of cases of rape and serious sexual offences, which inevitably involve the testimony of complainants, often the most vulnerable. Very often such cases are listed for trial a year or more after the case arrives in the Crown Court, as priority is given to other types of case, including those with custody time limits.

Under the policy, every Crown Court centre will be required to have one or more dedicated courtrooms for the trial of such cases. Investment will be made to ensure that appropriate facilities are provided, such as separate entrances and waiting rooms, and there will be additional support for complainants when attending court. Funding will be provided for the training of staff handling such cases, including trauma-informed training. The Government has also announced the launch of a Rape Justice Taskforce to focus on the problems which have arisen in these cases.

The changes under the Listing Practice Direction take effect on 1st October 2026. The central principle is that listing decisions must take account of “the human impact of delay”, whether on victims and complainants, other witnesses, or vulnerable defendants. Such cases will be prioritised and given a fixed trial date, so that there is greater certainty as to when the case will come on for trial.

The CBA strongly supports these changes. Whilst our criminal courts are under considerable pressure, it has been apparent for a long time that cases of rape and other trials involving vulnerable participants are being listed too far in the future. Victims and witnesses attending court have also been shocked to discover the poor facilities and the lack of specialist support, together with poor communication in advance of trial.

These changes will take place within the Crown Court as it stands. They do not create a different tier of courts, or any different rules of procedure. Crucially, they do not involve any removal of the right to trial by jury. Rape and other indictable-only offences have always been outside the scope of the proposals in the Courts and Tribunals Bill, and as recently as 2025 the Law Commission, in its report Evidence in sexual offences prosecutions, rejected calls for the removal of trial by jury in rape cases. What this policy will bring is dedicated courtrooms for cases involving the vulnerable, and a proper re-ordering of listing priorities.

Will Judge-only trials remain in the Bill?

A number of news reports have suggested that the Government will not be proceeding with the plan for Judge-only trials in the Crown Court when the Bill returns. On Saturday 19th September, the Telegraph reported that the Government was going to remove those provisions from the Bill, but still proceed with restrictions on the right to elect Crown Court trial in less serious cases.

The article appears to be well sourced, but carries the caveat that “Officials said that no final decisions have yet been taken.” It reported that the Government was placing the emphasis on restricting the right to elect in favour of a judicial decision on whether a case should be heard in the Crown Court, preventing perceived abuses in the exercise of the right to elect.

If it is right that the Government is no longer proceeding with Judge-only trials, that will be warmly welcomed by the profession. As we have said all along, juries have not caused the backlog of criminal cases, and restricting long-established rights to trial by jury is not the way to reduce Crown Court delays. Independent analysis by the Institute for Government showed that Judge-only trials would make a difference of only 1 to 2 per cent in the time taken to process cases in the Crown Court. Meanwhile, Judge-only trials would deliver a poorer form of justice whilst giving rise to many practical difficulties within our system of trials.

We sincerely hope that the new Government has listened to the evidence which has emerged in the debates of the last ten months and taken a step back from this misguided proposal. Trial by jury itself has been on trial, but we believe that the correct verdict is that it remains the best form of criminal justice.

The CBA will continue to campaign against the removal of the right to elect trial by jury. There is no evidence of widespread abuse of the right, and the discount for a guilty plea is the best way of encouraging defendants not to elect trial in inappropriate cases. The Bill as it stands provides that the sole determining factor in deciding whether to send a case for trial in the Crown Court is the predicted length of sentence. As we have pointed out, the perverse result would be that a defendant with multiple previous convictions is far more likely to receive a trial by jury than a person of good character.

At the very least, a discretion would be required to take account of factors such as the impact of loss of good character, loss of employment, loss of housing, and the consequences for a defendant’s family. In certain cases a defendant is advised to elect for legal reasons, such as to make an application to dismiss, or to pursue the more extensive disclosure regime in the Crown Court.

National Listing Framework

We are grateful to HHJ Martin Edmunds KC and HHJ Andrew Menary KC, who jointly presented the online lecture last week on the implementation of the new Practice Direction on Listing in the Criminal Courts, otherwise known as the National Listing Framework. Over 300 CBA members joined the discussion online.

Details of the changes are on the judiciary website: National Listing Framework: a new approach to criminal listing.

The framework takes effect on 1st October 2026. All criminal practitioners will need to familiarise themselves with the Practice Direction and the Guidance. It will change the way in which cases are listed, and remove local practices which have developed over time in ways that are inconsistent.

There will be two forms of listing: fixed date, or flexible date, which will cover a trial window. A flexible date listing will take the place of existing arrangements for warned list cases, backers and floating trials, which mean different things in different court centres. Where a case is given a flexible date, barristers and their clerks will need to communicate with the court in the weeks leading up to the trial window to confirm when the trial will take place.

The initial listing decision will be taken at PTPH, when cases will be allocated to the appropriate Priority Tier. That will mean taking into account the needs of complainants, witnesses and defendants. Advocates will need to arrive at PTPH with the information needed to decide on the allocation.

Andrew Thomas KC

Chair

The Criminal Bar Association

Kama Melly KC

Vice Chair

The Criminal Bar Association

The Criminal Bar Association

Suite 23, 9 Roper Close, Canterbury, Kent, CT2 7EP

This email was sent to |EMAIL|

Remove me from this audience