The Courts and Tribunals Bill has its Second Reading in the Lords tomorrow, the Black Barristers’ Committee launch, court custody suites, the CVP outage, and Treasury Counsel applications close tonight.
The CBA Briefing
Monday 26th October 2026
Let there be absolutely NO doubt: the Criminal Bar Association is fundamentally opposed to the proposed restrictions on the right to jury trial.
In this edition
•
CBA Black Barristers’ Committee Launch Party
•
Courts and Tribunals Bill: An Open Letter to Peers by HH Geoffrey Rivlin KC
•
Admission to Court Custody Suites
•
CVP Outage
•
Treasury Counsel Recruitment: closes today
•
A Correction to Last Week’s Bulletin
•
Criminal Law Week: this week’s updates
CBA Black Barristers’ Committee Launch Party
On Friday 6th November 2026, we celebrate the launch of the newly formed Black Barristers’ Committee at the De Vere Connaught Rooms between 18:00 and 01:00. We are delighted to announce that Baroness Shami Chakrabarti will be the guest speaker.
A limited number of tickets have now been released on a first come, first served basis.
Please join us to celebrate the launch of this committee. There will be refreshments, a DJ and dancing. The event is free to attend but by named invitation only.
Please contact Aaron Dolan before 28th October 2026 if you would like to attend.
Courts and Tribunals Bill – An Open Letter to Peers by HH Geoffrey Rivlin KC
The Second Reading of the Courts and Tribunals Bill in the House of Lords will take place tomorrow, Tuesday 27th October 2026. The CBA, Bar Council and Circuit Leaders remain united in their opposition to the continued attack on the right to trial by jury. On Tuesday 20th October 2026 we attended a meeting with peers, organised by Justice, to set out the case against the Bill. We are continuing to support the opposition to the Bill within the Lords.
By a combination of removing the right to elect Crown Court trial and giving the Government the power to double magistrates’ sentencing powers to 24 months imprisonment, the effect of the Bill would be to transfer 25,000 cases a year, including 5,500 trials, from the Crown Court to the Magistrates’ Court. The Bill would also introduce a power to conduct Judge-only trials in lengthy or complex cases and remove the automatic right of appeal from the Magistrates’ Court.
HH Geoffrey Rivlin KC, former Recorder of Westminster and Resident Judge at Southwark Crown Court, has written an open letter to peers setting out a critical analysis of the amended Bill ahead of its Second Reading.
The letter has been published by Red Lion Chambers as part of their FOCUS series. The article can be read here.
Geoffrey Rivlin questions the case for singling out serious fraud, the lack of a clear statutory threshold for when judge-alone trials should apply, the absence of a right of appeal, and the wider constitutional implications of the proposals. His letter to members of the House of Lords asks whether removing juries is really the answer to complexity, delay and the Crown Court backlog.
The letter explains how jury trial has long been recognised as a constitutional right in the law of England and Wales despite the ‘extraordinary’ claims to the contrary by both the Government and Lord Leveson. Parliamentary sovereignty means that constitutional rights can in principle be taken away, as can other rights such as free speech, the right to vote or basic liberty. However, it is important to recognise its status in the constitution. He writes: “The great tradition of trial by jury has an honoured place in the constitution, and its place is at the top table.” He says: “the proposals in the Bill do have constitutional implications – but they have been introduced without a manifesto, without a mandate, without consultation, and manifestly without caution.”
Geoffrey Rivlin goes on to consider the importance of trial by jury in the current-day society. His letter is rich in evidence of its importance, citing the defence of jury trial by Sir Keir Starmer KC and David Lammy KC MP themselves. Of particular importance is the discussion of the proposal for trial by Judge-alone in fraud and other lengthy or complex cases.
Admission to Court Custody Suites
Last week, both the CBA and the South Eastern Circuit were contacted by many members who had experienced difficulty gaining admission to the court custody suites for the purpose of client conferences. The problem last week appears to have arisen only in the courts in London and the South of England.
The problem which arose was that, without warning, Serco staff stopped accepting the official Professional Court User Scheme Card (the ‘Bar Pass’) as proof of identity for the purpose of custody visits. Barristers were asked to produce either a passport or driving licence, which many did not have. Particular difficulties were experienced by married barristers who continue to use their previous surname for professional reasons when their personal identity documents are now in their married name.
Together with Claire Davies KC, Leader of the South Eastern Circuit, we have met with HMPPS/Serco to discuss the issue. We have also raised the issue with HMCTS. The concern is of course the importance to our clients of conferences at court, and also to avoid any delays. We are challenging the approach which has been taken. The SEC has already sent out guidance which will be of relevance to those working in the affected courts.
If you have any difficulties, please contact the CBA by email.
CVP Outage
On Monday 19th October 2026, courts and tribunals across all jurisdictions experienced an ‘outage’ of the CVP video hearing platform. This prevented defendants appearing by video link, witnesses appearing at trial by video link and remote hearings where the advocates were due to appear by the link. At many court centres, this led to hearings being either cancelled or postponed.
We have raised this issue with HMCTS. We understand that their expectation is that Teams would be used as a backup in the event of CVP failure. On this occasion, that was not the experience at many court centres. We are asking for clarification and wider distribution of the ‘backup’ policy so as to minimise disruption to proceedings should this occur again.
Treasury Counsel Recruitment – Reminder
A reminder that applications for appointment as Senior Treasury Counsel and Treasury Counsel Monitorees close at midnight tonight.
Application packs are available via a request through the link on the Treasury Counsel page.
Correction to Last Week’s Bulletin
In last week’s CBA Bulletin we set out the figures for the success rate of appeals to the Crown Court against sentence. Although the percentage success rate (64%) was correctly stated, we gave the wrong total for appeals allowed.
The figures are these: in the 12 months to June 2026, there were 2,518 appeals against sentence. 668 appeals were later withdrawn. The total number of contested appeals was 1,850 of which 1,178 were successful (64%) and 672 unsuccessful (36%).
Criminal Law Week: this week’s updates
Key updates from issue 38 of Criminal Law Week:
•
Expert evidence: case and comment on admitting a streamlined forensic report as agreed evidence or hearsay: R. v PHN, CLW/26/38/1, CA.
•
Legal representation: whether the vulnerable unrepresented defendant’s conviction following a cut-throat murder trial was safe, with commentary: R. v Rodgers, CLW/26/38/3, Court of Appeal Northern Ireland.
•
Parole: case and comment on a lacuna in the law arising where a life prisoner wishes to challenge the Parole Board’s handling of a request to vary his post-release conditions: R. (Newlove) v Parole Board and anor, CLW/26/38/12, KBD (John Halford, sitting as a deputy High Court judge).
•
Terrorism: guidance on the operation of the defence under section 2(9) of the Terrorism Act 2006 to the offence under section 2(1)(c) of disseminating a terrorist publication being reckless as to whether it will encourage, induce or assist the commission, preparation, or instigation of acts of terrorism: R. v Hossen, CLW/26/38/6, CA.
•
Costs (unnecessarily or improperly incurred): whether a judge had been correct to award a defendant in a rape trial his costs following a successful submission of no case to answer, where the prosecution had had no realistic prospect of success: DPP v Inner London Crown Court, CLW/26/38/8, KBD (Obi J).
Andrew Thomas KC
Chair
The Criminal Bar Association
Kama Melly KC
Vice Chair
The Criminal Bar Association
The Criminal Bar Association
Suite 23, 9 Roper Close, Canterbury, Kent, CT2 7EP
This email was sent to |EMAIL|
Remove me from this audience
