Skip to content
The Criminal Bar Association

News

The CBA Briefing: 3rd November 2026

The CBA Briefing3rd November 2026

The Bar Pass is now accepted at court custody suites, the Lords debate the jury trial clauses, the Winter Conference on Saturday 5th December, and the week’s Criminal Law Week headlines.

The CBA Briefing

Tuesday 3rd November 2026

Let there be absolutely NO doubt: the Criminal Bar Association is fundamentally opposed to the proposed restrictions on the right to jury trial.

In this edition

•

Admission to court custody suites

•

Courts and Tribunals Bill: House of Lords Second Reading Debate

•

Jury equity

•

Law Society argues for equalisation of legal aid thresholds

•

The Winter Conference: Saturday 5th December

•

From Criminal Law Week: issue 39

This week

Admission to Court Custody Suites

Following our discussions with HMPPS, and with credit to Claire Davies KC, Leader of the South Eastern Circuit, we are pleased to confirm that we have agreed an interim arrangement for Bar Council Photographic ID (the ‘Bar Pass’) to be accepted as proof of identity at court custody suites.

This news was shared with us on Friday 30th October, and we hoped that court custody staff would be notified by the start of this week. Please be patient if the message has not yet been seen by everyone involved.

Although for the time being this is an interim arrangement, we are hopeful that this will be adopted as the fixed policy.

Thank you to everyone who contacted the CBA and SEC about this issue: your input has really made a difference. We are also extremely grateful to the leadership of HMPPS for their swift and constructive engagement to resolve this issue.

If anyone has further difficulties, please contact the CBA by email: the CBA office.

Courts and Tribunals Bill: House of Lords Second Reading Debate

The Second Reading of the Courts and Tribunals Bill took place in the House of Lords on Tuesday 27th October 2026. The debate can be read in Hansard here.

The CBA, together with the Bar Council and Circuit Leaders, are united in our opposition to those remaining clauses of the Courts and Tribunals Bill which represent an attack on trial by jury.

Those are:

•

Clause 1: Removal of the right to elect jury trial.

•

Clause 3: Trial by Judge-alone in long or complex cases.

•

Clause 5: Power to increase magistrates’ sentencing powers to 2 years’ imprisonment.

•

Clause 6: Removal of the automatic right of appeal against conviction.

Our mandate is clear. In July 2025, more than 2,000 CBA members took part in our survey on criminal courts reform. More than 94 per cent of members supported the retention of the right to trial by jury for all either-way offences. The same proportion, over 94 per cent, also supported the retention of the automatic right of appeal against conviction from the magistrates’ court to the Crown Court.

As for magistrates’ sentencing powers, a clear majority was against making permanent the increase from 6 months to 12 months, which at the time of the survey had only recently occurred. Little were we to know that the Government were planning to go further and allow for an increase to 2 years.

The decision on criminal courts reform currently stands with Parliament. Our opposition has already successfully defeated the proposal for Judge-only trials for lesser offences before the Crown Court. However, the attack on jury trials has not gone away and the CBA are actively engaged with parliamentarians in both houses in opposing the remaining threats within the Bill.

The House of Lords Debate

The debate was opened by Lord Lemos, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Justice. Lord Lemos argued that the proposals in the Bill are not simply about tackling the Crown Court backlog but about “rebuilding a system which works better for everyone”. He said that the Bill’s purpose is to strengthen the magistrates’ courts. Although the Bill would grant the Government the power to increase magistrates’ sentencing powers to 24 months’ imprisonment, he revealed that the Government’s intention is to implement this change next year (2027) with an initial increase to 18 months. Lord Lemos said that the removal of the right to elect “will help ensure that valuable Crown Court time is reserved for cases that genuinely require it”.

Lord Garnier KC (Conservative) and Lord Rooker (Labour) both raised concerns about the adequacy of scrutiny of the Bill by the House of Commons, highlighting the limited time which had been allocated for debate. Lord Garnier said that the Bill had “huge constitutional, financial and practical importance for all of us as citizens and for the institutions of justice” and its significance had been treated by the Government “with disdain”.

For the Conservatives, Lord Ashcombe acknowledged the problem of delays in the criminal courts but argued that the measures in the Bill were not the right solution. He said that trial by jury functions well and questioned whether public confidence would be diminished by removing the right to elect.

Lord Garnier KC argued that practical measures were required to reduce the backlog, not reducing the ability of a citizen to obtain trial by jury. He highlighted the findings of David Lammy MP’s own report on the treatment of Black, Asian, and Minority Ethnic individuals in the criminal courts, including his conclusions on the importance of jury trial.

Lord (Simon) Murray spoke against the removal of the automatic right of appeal to the Crown Court. He said that it provided an important safeguard, highlighting the success rate of 56 per cent in contested appeals and 40 per cent overall. He argued that the additional complexity would add to the burdens upon both magistrates and Crown Court judges.

Lord Bellamy KC was one of several speakers who raised concerns about the ability of magistrates’ courts to cope with the large influx of more serious, more complex cases. He proposed instead a ‘twin track’ approach of accelerating the efficiency proposals in Lord Leveson’s report together with the reclassification of lesser offences as summary-only.

Lord Marks KC, for the Liberal Democrats, said: “We believe that the right to elect a trial by jury is a cornerstone of our liberty. Juries democratise criminal justice… The public trust juries. They think the system fair. They believe that 12 heads are better than one.” He highlighted the fact that the Bill would give magistrates alone the power to decide allocation, without even a right of appeal, and also the absence of discretionary grounds for allocation to the Crown Court.

Lord (Michael) Howard KC, Baroness Chakrabarti and Baroness (Helena) Kennedy KC argued that jury trials provide an important democratic safeguard. Lord Howard spoke about the significance of the right to trial by jury for individual defendants facing accusations in more serious cases. He also spoke about the power which the Government wished to grant itself to add to the list of offences in respect of which the right to trial by jury could be removed on the basis of the length or complexity of the case, describing the provision as a “Joseph Stalin clause”. Baroness Chakrabarti described juries as “a crucial participatory and legitimising factor of our system and society”. She highlighted the fact that the verdicts of juries protect our judges from opprobrium and that they provide “a final safety valve against oppressive laws and prosecutions.”

Many cross-bench peers expressed their support for the Government’s decision to abandon the proposal for Judge-only trials in a Crown Court Bench Division, but had differing views on further reforms.

Lord (Ken) MacDonald KC spoke about the impact which funding cuts have had on the criminal justice system, including on the CPS. He opposed the changes within the Bill, arguing that the potential gains in efficiency are so small that they do not justify the removal of the right to jury trial. He said that the Magistrates’ Courts are not in a fit state to deal with the influx of work, especially as volunteer magistrates would not be able to sit for 3 or 4 continuous days to hear more contentious cases.

Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd said that he agrees that structural reform of the criminal courts is required but argued that the full range of options requires further examination. He questioned whether increasing the sentencing powers of magistrates was the correct answer and expressed support for the trial of cases by a Judge and two magistrates.

Lord (Alex) Carlile KC said that the courts should be willing to accept reform but said that there were still several issues to be addressed before a decision is taken on extending magistrates’ sentencing powers, including questions around targets for recruitment, training, the ability to try multi-day cases and the requirement for adequate reasons for their decisions. He also expressed support for granting defendants the right to elect trial by a Judge alone.

Lord Leveson said that the criminal courts are in crisis; more funding and greater efficiency are required, but that alone is not enough. He acknowledged that the Government had not taken forward his own proposals but said that structural change was required in order to manage the increasing length and complexity of criminal cases. He posed the question: “If not this, then what?”

The Bill now moves to the Committee Stage, beginning on Tuesday 10th November 2026, when members of the House of Lords will be able to consider both opposition to individual clauses and detailed amendments.

Jury Equity: Proposed Amendment to the Bill

The Courts and Tribunals Bill also presents an opportunity for Parliament itself to put forward other proposals for reform.

An amendment jointly proposed by Baroness Shami Chakrabarti, Viscount Hailsham (Douglas Hogg KC) and Baroness Kennedy KC is headed “Jury equity and protection for advocates appearing before juries”. It is designed to protect advocates from prosecution for contempt of court for referring to the principle of ‘jury equity’ in a trial before a jury.

There is a clear inconsistency in the law as it stands. Juries are lawfully entitled to decide a case ‘in accordance with their conscience’, and the case of Warner [2024] EWHC 918 (KB) decided that it is lawful for jurors to be told of that fact outside of court. There are real concerns that any barrister should face proceedings for contempt of court for, allegedly, making even an oblique reference to jury equity in a closing speech.

This amendment would be a welcome clarification of the law. It would remove the threat to advocates who act with the genuine intention of addressing the jury within the confines of the common law.

Law Society supports campaign on equalising Legal Aid thresholds

One of the issues laid bare by the Courts and Tribunals Bill is the unequal provision for Legal Aid in the Crown Court and Magistrates’ Courts.

Criminal Legal Aid is subject to means-testing, based on the gross income of the defendant and, if they have a partner, of their partner. Adjustments are made to take account of dependants. In the Magistrates’ Court, eligibility is also subject to an ‘interests of justice’ test.

The upper-limit threshold in the Magistrates’ Court is £22,325. In the Crown Court it is £37,500. That difference in treatment has historically been justified on the basis that Magistrates’ Courts are only dealing with ‘minor’ offences, but that has changed. Already, the sentencing powers of magistrates in either-way cases have been increased to 12 months’ imprisonment, and under the Courts and Tribunals Bill it could be increased to 24 months’ imprisonment.

In an article for the Daily Telegraph last week, the President of the Law Society, Brett Dixon, raised concerns about the risk of miscarriages of justice. He wrote:

“Standalone reforms and isolated injections of funding will not create the resilient justice system that every healthy society needs. Reforms that restrict jury trials, increase the seriousness of cases heard in the magistrates’ courts, or narrow appeal rights, risk weakening the fairness and public confidence they are intended to restore.

So, we need to look at two things. First, whether the proposed reforms will achieve the Government’s stated aim of reducing delays and relieving pressure on the criminal courts.

Second, whether those changes, even if successful, will strengthen or undermine the fairness and integrity of the justice system as a whole.

At the heart of this issue is an undeniable fact: each part of the system impacts on and interacts with every other part. Investment in legal aid, for example, is essential and cannot be treated as an afterthought.

The Government’s impact assessment does not address the disparity between the magistrates’ and Crown Court means tests.

Under the current system, defendants are more likely to qualify for legal aid in the Crown Court than in the magistrates’ court. Unless eligibility thresholds are modernised, reforms that see more serious cases dealt with in the magistrates’ court risk leaving more defendants without representation when facing a substantial prison term.

That would not only risk people’s right to a fair trial, but also slow proceedings and place further strain on an already overstretched system.

At a time when duty solicitor numbers continue to decline because of low fee rates, increasing demand without addressing the cause of decreasing capacity risks exacerbating an already fragile situation and undermining the very efficiencies these reforms seek to achieve.

Moving more serious and complex cases into the magistrates’ court without addressing these underlying pressures risks pushing the system beyond breaking point.”

The full article is here.

The Winter Conference

Our Winter Conference takes place on Saturday 5th December 2026 at the De Vere Grand Connaught Rooms. The programme covers a criminal practice update, sexual offences, sentencing for murder, fraud, human rights and crime, prior fault criminalisation, and ancillary orders, with two sessions run as an Assize Seminar with the universities of Oxford, Cambridge and UCL. Please look out next week for when bookings open; we hope to see many of you there.

From Criminal Law Week

Key updates from this week’s issue of Criminal Law Week (issue 39):

Drugs: correct sentence for a young offender who had brought 388g of cannabis with him to his attempted murder trial with intent to supply, with commentary: R. v Thomas, CLW/26/39/4, CA.

Misconduct in public office: sentencing of offences committed by a prison officer and serving prisoner as a secondary party, with commentary: Att.-Gen.’s Reference (R. v Winkless), CLW/26/39/6, CA.

Sentences for public protection: case and comment concerning an appellant who was given an IPP sentence for an offence for which IPP was not available: R. v Haycock, CLW/26/39/12, CA.

Prohibited steps order: provision inserted into the Children Act 1989 requiring the Crown Court to make an order where one parent has killed another is brought into force on 18th December 2026: Victims and Prisoners Act 2024 (Commencement No. 12 and Transitional Provision) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/1126), CLW/26/39/18.

With thanks to Criminal Law Week for these headlines.

Kama Melly KC

Vice Chair

The Criminal Bar Association

The Criminal Bar Association

Suite 23, 9 Roper Close, Canterbury, Kent, CT2 7EP

This email was sent to |EMAIL|

Remove me from this audience