Custody Suites and Bar Pass: Update
HMPPS have today published revised guidance to contractors on the acceptance of Bar Pass as proof of identity. The new guidance states as follows:
“With immediate effect, PECS Contractors are authorised to accept the Bar Council photographic identification pass, issued under the Professional Court User Scheme, as sufficient identification for a barrister entering an HMCTS court custody suite to undertake professional legal visits.
When a valid Bar Council photographic identification pass is presented:
• no additional photographic identification is required; and
• no letter or other written confirmation identifying the client being visited is required.”
This now resolves the issue for the foreseeable future. We are very grateful to HMPPS and all others who have worked swiftly and effectively to clarify the position.
AGFS Fees: Update from CLAAB
The Criminal Legal Aid Advisory Board (CLAAB) met last week, for the first time under the leadership of its new Chair Ruth Evans. The CBA, Bar Council, Law Society, LCCSA and CPS were represented at the meeting as well as the MoJ and LAA.
We were informed at the meeting that the Government now expects to publish its final response to the AGFS consultation in December. Bar representatives expressed their disappointment that it will have taken two years from the start of discussions, and a year from the announcement of £34 million investment, to reach a final decision. We are also continuing to press to ensure that the Regulations which are necessary to implement the change will be published simultaneously so that they can take immediate effect.
Background
In December 2025, the Government made this announcement:
“To recognise the vital role of the legal sector in rescuing the courts from this crisis, legal professionals will be boosted by a significant additional investment in criminal legal aid fees for advocates of up to £34m a year.
The additional investment into the independent Bar, those hard-working professionals who defend and prosecute, will bolster the workforce that ultimately powers the courts and keeps the wheels of justice turning.
Today’s response will form part of the Government’s commitment to safer streets by reducing the court backlog, speeding up hearings for victims, and rebuilding public confidence in the criminal justice system.”
Nearly a year later, barristers have not seen a single penny of this additional funding. In January, we asked the Government to make an immediate across-the-board increase in legal aid funding so as to speed up implementation. The MoJ chose instead to focus on ‘targeted’ increases, which has resulted in nearly a year of delay.
Barristers are still working at the rates which were set four years ago following the Bar’s action. The increases which we have suggested are not unreasonable, and are supported by independent reviewers including Lord Bellamy KC, Lord Leveson and CLAAB.
Lord Bellamy’s 2021 Independent Review of Criminal Legal Aid found that the fees paid under AGFS were ‘barely sustainable’ and were causing “an exodus from the middle”. His independent recommendation was that an immediate 15% increase was required. That was not, in his words, merely “an opening bid” (see para 1.38 of his report).
The Bar’s action in 2022 was designed to secure the increases which Lord Bellamy recommended. Four years on, the delays in making further increases, all the time leaving fees to be eroded by inflation, will leave the criminal Bar in a worse position than we were in following the Bar’s action.
Progress towards annual reviews
In its response to Lord Leveson’s Independent Report on the Criminal Courts, the Government announced in October that it ‘accepts in principle’ Recommendation 154, which is to “commit to reviewing legal aid fees and reporting on this on an annual basis from 2027”. The Government wrote:
“The Government agrees that there is merit in the idea of reviewing fees on a more regular basis. This has the potential to improve financial planning of the Government and legal aid providers and thereby support the market. The development of any review mechanism should take place after court reforms have bedded in, and after current funding discussions, including an uplift of £34 million on the AGFS, have concluded. Accepting in principle means the Government will need to consider various factors, including the scope and frequency of any review, as well as the role of structures alongside fee levels.”
That suggested timescale, to develop any review mechanism “after court reforms have bedded in”, is not an acceptable solution. Lord Leveson’s recommendation was to address the current problems of recruiting and retaining solicitors and barristers in the criminal justice workforce. We are already 2 years into the present round of fee discussions and yet to see any results. This glacial pace is not acceptable and must not happen again.
We are pleased that the issue of annual review is already on the CLAAB agenda and we hope that this commitment will be taken forward immediately. CLAAB is an independent body and we hope that with its support the work towards a system of annual review can be progressed.
The Government are not going to be able to deliver ‘swift justice for victims’ if they do not support those committed barristers and solicitors who are willing to undertake publicly funded work in the criminal courts.
Legal Aid and the Courts and Tribunals Bill
Concerns have been raised with the Government about the impact of the Courts and Tribunals Bill on access to justice. Legal aid is not as widely available in the magistrates’ courts as in the Crown Court. On the most recent available figures, 48% of defendants facing imprisonable charges in the magistrates’ courts represented themselves.
This is a concern about access to justice, with many middle-income earners facing the risk of conviction and imprisonment without legal representation. It also applies to the changes to appeals against conviction from the magistrates’ courts, with the proposal that appellants would have to file detailed grounds of appeal in order to get permission to appeal. There is a genuine risk of miscarriages of justice.
These issues were highlighted by the Daily Telegraph last week in their article.
The article sets out many of the constructive proposals which the CBA and other professional groups have put forward as practical ways of tackling the backlog in the Crown Court and magistrates’ courts. As the article said:
“The CBA has proposed retaining the one-year cap on magistrates’ sentencing powers and the right to elect trial, but then reclassifying a dozen offences such as assault on an emergency worker and drug possession as crimes that could only be tried by justices of the peace to reduce the number of cases going up to Crown Court.
It would also support increasing the discount criminals receive on their sentences if they plead guilty at the first opportunity, from 33 per cent to 40 per cent as an incentive to reduce the number of trials.”
The CBA and professional bodies will be meeting with Ministry of Justice representatives next week to discuss the implications of these changes.
Launch of the CBA Black Barristers’ Committee
On Friday 6th November 2026, over 300 colleagues and supporters attended the launch event for the CBA Black Barristers’ Committee in London.
Keynote speeches were given by Keir Monteith KC, the founding chair of the Committee, and Baroness Shami Chakrabarti. Other speakers were Christine Giscombe of the youth work charity Spark2Life, who was introduced by Stephen Akinsanya OBE, and Ade Adedeji of Manchester youth justice organisation Kids of Colour.
Keir spoke about Black excellence: celebrating the outstanding achievements of the Black barristers who had inspired his career and those who continue to excel in the legal professions. Keir spoke of how he and his Black colleagues have always had to work harder and to a higher standard than others to achieve, and the importance of a Bar and Judiciary that reflects our society. He talked about the need to confront the systemic problems which continue to stand in the way of career progression, including the under-representation of Black Judges in the Crown Court and the fact that there are no Black judges at all currently in the Court of Appeal, or have ever been in the Supreme Court. Keir reiterated our need to take collective, personal responsibility for what has not improved and ensuring we take opportunities for change. That change starts with all of us, the Bar and the Judiciary, to ensure that the increased representation we are seeing within the criminal Bar makes its way across all levels of the judiciary. He recognised that the new Committee is just part of the framework that will be required to dismantle the obstacles faced by Black barristers.
Baroness Chakrabarti welcomed the creation of the committee and the need for solidarity across the Bar to overcome the systemic hurdles encountered by Black barristers. She said we cannot simply rely on change improving over time without working together to drive the principles of diversity and equality forward.
Ade spoke powerfully about his own experiences in being convicted of a crime he did not commit, his struggle for justice and about understanding young people’s experiences in the criminal justice system.
Barrister representatives from over 50 different sets of Chambers attended, including from all six circuits, and members of the employed Bar. We were joined by colleagues from the judiciary, including representatives of the Association of Black Judges, Whipple LJ (the lead judge for diversity and inclusion), Theis J and Poole J. Kirsty Brimelow KC (Chair), Heidi Stonecliffe KC (Vice Chair) and Jim Morris (CEO) represented the Bar Council. Many solicitor guests also attended, including Zach White (incoming Chair of the LCCSA). There were representatives also from many allied groups and organisations including Justice, Liberty, the Howard League, 10,000 Black Interns, Appeal and Unjust.
Congratulations to Keir, Nneka Akudolu KC (Vice Chair) and all of their committee on the successful launch. Thanks also to Matilda Robinson-Murphy and Aaron Dolan for their work in organising the event, and to former Chair Riel Karmy-Jones KC who championed the creation of the Committee.
The committee is officially formed from today, Monday 9th November 2026, and details of its members can be found on the CBA website here.
Courts and Tribunals Bill: Two House of Lords Committees Intervene
Two separate House of Lords committees published reports last week raising serious concerns about aspects of the Courts and Tribunals Bill. As one commentator suggested, they have made it clear that the upper house must not be taken for granted.
The report of the Constitution Committee
The Constitution Committee has the standing role of examining all public bills for their constitutional implications and providing advice on constitutional issues. It is chaired by Lord Strathclyde, former Leader of the House of Lords, with members including Lord Burnett, former Lord Chief Justice, Lord Bellamy KC, Lord Waldegrave, former Cabinet Minister, Lord Carwyn Jones, barrister and former First Minister of Wales, Lord Beith, former Deputy Lib Dem Leader, and Baroness Hamwee, former Chair of the London Assembly.
The Constitution Committee’s report on the Courts and Tribunals Bill was published on Wednesday 4th November 2026. It is a 5 page report which can be read here.
The Constitution Committee said that the way in which the Bill has been drafted means that its effects are “at times opaque and hence difficult to scrutinise.” They have asked the Government to produce schedules to show how the legislation will actually look in its final form.
The Committee also highlighted the constitutional significance of the proposed changes to jury trials and the grant of delegated powers to allow the Government to vary the maximum sentence which can be imposed by a magistrates’ court. The Committee said:
“A right to a fair trial is of fundamental constitutional importance, and trial by jury occupies a central position in the criminal justice system. This does not mean that changes to trial by jury are necessarily constitutionally unacceptable: the system has evolved over many years and primary legislation can limit, and in the past has limited, the availability of trial by jury. However, it does mean that changes to trial by jury are of constitutional importance, and should be made with due care and attention and only on the basis of a strong justification by the Government. …
The House should consider carefully whether these measures are a proportionate response to significant pressures in the criminal justice system. To inform the House’s consideration, the Government should provide a detailed explanation of how these provisions will work in practice and the effect they will have on the courts and participants in cases.”
The Constitution Committee requested a response from the Government by 4th January 2027.
The Committee also recommended changes to the Bill’s provisions increasing magistrates’ sentencing powers, stating that any future change should require an affirmative resolution from Parliament.
The report of the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee
On Friday 6th November 2026, the House of Lords Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee (‘DPRRC’) published its own report on the Bill.
The DPRRC’s role includes reporting on whether any proposed Bill would grant ‘inappropriate delegated legislative powers’ to the Government.
In their report, the DPRRC highlighted the significance of the power in Clause 3 of the Bill to extend trial without a jury from fraud cases to other serious offences. They liken it to the powers which Henry VIII granted himself to issue orders overriding the will of Parliament. The DPRRC say:
“This is a Henry VIII power. We have often said that Henry VIII powers are controversial, particularly when they confer on Ministers significant powers to amend primary legislation. In ‘Democracy Denied?’ (2021) we argued that the appropriate threshold between primary and secondary legislation should be founded on the overarching principle that the principal aspects of policy should be on the face of a bill and only its detailed implementation left to delegated legislation. The power … may be exercised to add to the offences listed in the Bill that may be tried without a jury.
In our view, the question about which offences are suitable for inclusion in that list is a fundamental component of the policy contained in the Bill (and is an issue about which there is likely to be a wide divergence of opinion). We do not consider it appropriate for such a key aspect of the policy to be left to the less rigorous parliamentary scrutiny afforded to secondary legislation.”
The committee were also concerned that the justification for granting this power was simply in case it might be needed in years to come. The DPRRC concluded:
“In our view, this is an inappropriate delegation of power. It confers on the Secretary of State a significant power to amend, by order, principal aspects of the policy contained in the Bill. We are unconvinced by the Government’s justification for the power in the Memorandum.”
The committee went on to consider the corresponding provisions in Clause 5 to increase sentencing powers in the magistrates’ court. They said that this also amounts to a ‘Henry VIII’ clause. They concluded:
“As with the power contained in clause 3(5) (referred to above), we consider that the Government has failed to justify the inclusion of the power in clause 5(1) and we recommend that it is removed from the Bill.”
The CBA welcomes the recognition by these two important committees of the constitutional significance of the right to a fair trial, and the central role which the right to trial by jury plays. These are significant warnings which highlight not just the concerns about the process but the dangers of acting “without strong justification”. The Government are yet to provide convincing evidence that such far reaching changes are either necessary or workable.
Criminal Law Week: Updates (Issue 40)
Key updates from this week’s issue of Criminal Law Week:
-
Documentary evidence – Privy Council rules in relation to the practice of permitting the prosecution to show the jury unchallenged documents in the course of its opening speech, and the process for identifying documents that have been authenticated by a witness: Cassell v The King, CLW/26/40/1.
-
Live links – Court of Appeal gives guidance for when it is proposed that a judge appears at a sentencing hearing by live link: R. v Priestley, CLW/26/40/3.
-
Indecent photographs – case and comment on the approach to sentencing a teenager who had sexted, aged 17, with his girlfriend who was just shy of 16: R. v Vanrell-Harris, CLW/26/40/4, CA.
-
Legal aid – whether all the advocates in a multi-handed murder case will be entitled to a band 1.2 fee under the AGFS banding document where any of the defendants has a previous conviction for murder: R. v Dodsworth, CLW/26/40/6, SCCO (Costs Judge Leonard).
-
Crime and Policing Act 2026 – various provisions brought into force on different dates, including on paedophile manuals, domestic abuse protection orders, stalking protection orders, and suspending IP addresses and internet domain names: SI 2026/1158, CLW/26/40/7.
-
Domestic Abuse Best Listing Scheme – expedited listing and case-management pathway for suitable domestic abuse cases in the magistrates’ courts and Crown Court, operating within the existing National Listing Framework: CLW/26/40/12.

