Skip to content
The Criminal Bar Association

Year in Review

Year in Review – 2024

The year at a glance

2024 was the year in which a long-running national emergency in the criminal courts collided with a change of government. The Crown Court backlog passed 74,000 cases, with trials being listed three and four years into the future; a Conservative administration that had presided over a decade of cuts gave way in July to a Labour Government inheriting a justice system that, in the Association's words from October, was "as broken as the criminal justice system because, unlike other systems, this one has never been seen to matter sufficiently to be ring-fenced". Against that backdrop, the Association brought its Wellbeing Protocol into national effect, supported the Criminal Legal Aid Advisory Board through its long-awaited report, and prepared the ground for the two great reviews – Gauke on sentencing, Leveson on the criminal courts – that would dominate 2025.

Who was Chair

For the first two-thirds of the calendar year the Chair was Tana Adkin KC of 15NBS Chambers (term September 2023 to August 2024), with Mary Prior KC of 36 Group Chambers as her Vice-Chair. On 1st September 2024 Mary Prior KC took up the chairmanship for the 2024 to 2025 term, with Riel Karmy-Jones KC of Red Lion Chambers, previously Chair of the RASSO Sub-Committee, as her Vice-Chair. The change was confirmed in the Monday Message of 5th August 2024.

Key themes

The Crown Court backlog and Crown Court sitting days

The backlog dominated every Monday Message of the year. The Monday Message of 30th September 2024 used a Wembley image to make the figures human: if each of the then 70,000 outstanding cases involved a complainant and a defendant, "the people waiting for justice would fill Wembley Stadium twice over". By October the figure had risen further. The Resident Judge at Snaresbrook had bucked the trend, working with court staff and practitioners to reduce that court's backlog by 13%, only to be told that sitting days were being cut. Southwark Crown Court, primarily a serious fraud court, had four of its sixteen courtrooms closed. The Monday Message of 21st October recorded that "just last week, 500 court rooms stood empty to save money" – rooms otherwise reserved for rape trials, fraud trials and offences of serious violence.

The most consequential single decision of the year was the December 2024 cap on Crown Court sitting days at 110,000 for 2025/26 – despite HMCTS having advised in August 2024 that the maximum capacity was 113,000. The Justice Select Committee had recommended a minimum of 110,000 sitting days for a minimum of five years, back in April 2022, when the backlog stood at around 60,000; that recommendation had not been implemented in the years since.

The CBA Wellbeing Protocol comes into national effect

The most significant institutional achievement of the year was the entry into force of the CBA Wellbeing Protocol on 27th April 2024, announced by the Chair at the CBA Spring RASSO Conference. The Protocol had begun life at the start of 2021 as a draft prepared by the Judicial Liaison Committee, then under the joint chairmanship of Jonathan Higgs KC and Tana Adkin KC. It had been refined through extensive consultation with the Bar Standards Board (where the work of Sam Stein KC was particularly important) and with the Crown Prosecution Service. The BSB confirmed that rC30 of the Code of Conduct already permitted barristers to decline instructions that would require them to work outside ordinary working time. By the Spring RASSO Conference, Chambers across the South Eastern Circuit had agreed to adopt the Protocol en bloc, with several sets on other Circuits "jumping the gun", and the Protocol moved to national rollout in the autumn under the leadership of the Wellbeing Committee – Jonathan Higgs KC, Szilvia Booker, Nigel Edwards KC, Fiona McAddy, Grace Ong, Sam Stein KC, Diana Wilson and Gerwyn Wise. The reasoning was set out in the Monday Message of 25th November: the Protocol exists "to retain the criminal barristers that we have and to recruit new ones".

The point was reinforced by an unusual ally. In her introduction to the Crown Court Compendium in July 2024, the Lady Chief Justice, Baroness Carr of Walton-on-the-Hill, wrote that judges "need to remember that advocates have lives (and obligations) outside of the trial". The Association quoted her at length, observing that most research suggests the maximum hours that can be worked for optimum productivity and health is fifty per week.

Section 28 and the pre-recorded evidence system

The roll-out of the new pre-recorded evidence (PRE) system was beset by technical difficulties through the autumn. On 14th October 2024 temporary measures had to be put in place to allow Section 28 hearings to continue. The temporary measures remained in force until 3rd March 2025, when the technical issues were declared resolved. Throughout, the Association maintained pressure on the Ministry of Justice for the fee for Section 28 work – a "bolt-on" of £670 plus VAT – to be uplifted to a level that would actually retain advocates willing to conduct trials of cases involving complainant cross-examination.

Fees, the CLAAB and the Bellamy promise

The Association's principal vehicle for fees and conditions remained the Criminal Legal Aid Advisory Board (CLAAB), chaired since mid-2023 by HHJ Deborah Taylor. CLAAB produced a report in July 2024. The Government – by then a new Government – chose to publish it on 14th November 2024. The report recommended substantial, immediate additional funding to meet the aims of Sir Christopher Bellamy's 2021 Criminal Legal Aid Review (CLAR) – the implementation of which had been a foundational commitment after the Days of Action of 2022 – and an immediate uplift in RASSO fees. The Association had been pressing for both since September 2024 and would continue to press throughout 2025. The CBA Remuneration Committee, led by Richard Christie KC, prepared submissions to the Treasury for the Spending Review process. Andrew Thomas KC led the Association's response to the Sentencing Consultation, published in late November.

The criminal Bar and the General Election

The General Election of 4th July 2024 produced a change of government. Labour took office; Shabana Mahmood MP was appointed Secretary of State for Justice and Lord Chancellor; Heidi Alexander was appointed Justice Minister, later replaced by Sarah Sackman KC MP. The Association engaged constructively with the new ministerial team from the start. By the autumn, however, the tone was sharpening: the new administration's decision to reduce Crown Court sitting days, while announcing two parallel reviews – David Gauke on sentencing and Sir Brian Leveson on the criminal courts – was met with some bluntness. The Monday Message of 21st October recorded that the CBA had offered to assist the Gauke Sentencing Review and "we understand that there will not be a representative of the criminal bar on that board. We have offered to help for free. The lack of respect for us is palpable."

By the year's end, after the early-release scheme and the sitting day cap, the Monday Message of 28th October summed up the new dispensation: "It is the rule of law that enables justice. […] An independent criminal Bar, just like an independent and robust solicitors' profession, is a critical part of the rule of law."

Consultations responded to

  • CBA Response to the Sentencing Consultation (Andrew Thomas KC and team), published November 2024, in response to the Gauke Sentencing Review.
  • CBA Submissions to the Treasury for the Comprehensive Spending Review, prepared by Richard Christie KC and the Remuneration Committee, autumn 2024.
  • Evidence to the Senedd Standards of Conduct Committee Inquiry.
  • CBA Response in relation to the Crown Court Compendium and judicial wellbeing.
  • Continuing engagement with the CLAAB process throughout the year – the CLAAB Report was published on 14th November 2024.

Notable events

The CBA Spring RASSO Conference of 27th April 2024 will be remembered as the moment the Wellbeing Protocol came into national effect. The Association's Summer Reception was held on 12th July 2024 at Sea Containers Buildings, London, with guests invited to "wear something sparkling to dance in" – a fitting send-off to Tana Adkin KC's term. The CBA Winter Conference took place on Saturday 30th November 2024 at Inner Temple, beginning at 0900 hrs and concluding at 1645 hrs, with the keynote address given by HH Chris Kinch KC, former Resident Judge at Woolwich Crown Court, on a programme covering human trafficking, protest offences, fraud, developments in criminal law and sentencing.

The Education and Training Committee, then chaired by Charlotte Newell KC and Paul Jarvis KC, ran an extensive lecture series throughout the year. The CBA podcast continued. The South Eastern Circuit's Advanced International Advocacy Course ran successfully at Keble College. Aaron Dolan administered the Winter Conference and the broader programme.

Government and regulatory landscape

The principal regulatory developments of the year were institutional. Sir Brian Leveson KC was commissioned to lead an Independent Review of the Criminal Courts, with Part 1 (addressing the structure of trial, including the possible restriction of jury trial) to report in 2025. David Gauke was commissioned to lead an Independent Sentencing Review. The Crown Prosecution Service inspectorate, HMCPSI, conducted thematic work. The Government implemented a 12-month pilot from May 2024 enabling free transcripts of sentencing remarks for the families of deceased victims in murder and manslaughter cases, and for victims of rape – a step the Association supported.

The Bar Standards Board continued its work on the Code of Conduct in the wellbeing space, and progressed proceedings against a former Chair of the Association on charges of professional misconduct, the determination on which would not be published until 19th March 2025. Tana Adkin KC, as Vice-Chair under Kirsty Brimelow KC and then as Chair, had reported the matter through the proper channels when it was raised.

The CPS continued to support the CBA Wellbeing Protocol in relation to RASSO work, including by extending parts of its Employee Assistance Programme to all advocates dealing with potentially distressing casework – a 24/7 helpline available free and confidentially.

In memoriam

Anthony Berry KC died on 1st October 2024 after an illness. An early Secretary of the CBA, he fought tenaciously for the interests of the Association's members, led the struggle for better recompense for the criminal Bar and gave no quarter to those he negotiated with. He joined John Hazan's chambers at 4 Brick Court at an early stage of his career, rapidly forged a successful practice as a junior and took silk at an early age, with homicide a specialism. In 2000, upon the appointment of Anne Rafferty to the High Court Bench, he became Head of Chambers and oversaw the move to 9 Bedford Row, a position he held for an unparalleled sixteen years.

Looking ahead from the time

The Monday Messages of the late autumn flagged three priorities for the year ahead: implementation of the CLAAB Report and the Bellamy promise on fees; engagement with the Leveson and Gauke reviews; and protection of an independent criminal Bar at a time when, on the Government's own decisions on sitting days, the system showed no sign of being treated as the ring-fenced public service it needed to be. As the year closed, the Chair's office wrote: "We have warned since 2018 that the consequences of such cuts would be that criminal barristers would leave the profession and that the system would break."

← Back to Year in Review