Skip to content
The Criminal Bar Association

Wellbeing

Wellbeing Survey 2021: analysis

In January 2021 the CBA launched its wellbeing protocol and opened the consultation phase with a survey of its own membership. Nine short questions. Support for the protocol was virtually unanimous, ranging from 92% to 100%.

Why the survey was short

The Committee was conscious that practitioners are asked to complete surveys on what can seem an almost weekly basis, and that survey fatigue was setting in. The questions were therefore kept short, and there were only nine of them, designed so that the answers could be interpreted clearly.

Each question offered simple agreement or disagreement with a proposition. Offering a range of alternatives would have diluted and confused the overall picture: on the length of the court day, for example, some argued for 16:15, some for 16:00, and one perhaps rather optimistic respondent for 15:50. What the question established instead was that 98.7% agreed there should be a defined ordinary cut-off time at all.

The questions and the responses

  • Q1

    Do you agree with the CBA protocol that the court day should ordinarily end no later than 16:30?

    98.7% agreed1.3% disagreed

    Paragraph 1 of the protocol proposes that the court day should ordinarily end no later than 16:30, and paragraph 2 makes clear that a court may sit later, or earlier than 10:00, in exceptional circumstances, provided enquiry is made of practitioners’ commitments first. Respondents differed on the ideal time, some arguing for 16:15, some for 16:00 and one for 15:50, but 98.7% agreed there should be a defined ordinary cut-off.

  • Q2

    Do you agree with the CBA protocol that, in addition to lunch breaks, courts should not ordinarily sit for longer than an hour and a half without a break?

    92.15% agreed7.85% disagreed

    The one issue that drew the widest range of views, with strong feeling on both sides. The comments from those who disagreed were considered with particular care; several took the view that a mid-session break is desirable but should be a matter for the trial judge rather than a protocol.

  • Q3

    Do you agree with the CBA protocol that, where possible, listing should make every effort to accommodate availability?

    100% agreed0% disagreed

    The only proposition in the survey on which there was no dissent at all.

  • Q4

    Do you agree with the CBA protocol that there should be a cut-off point in the evening and at weekends, after which advocates should not be required to respond to emails until the following day?

    95.4% agreed4.16% disagreed

    The analysis observes that computers, mobile phones and smartphones have allowed communication to continue long after the ordinary working day has ended.

  • Q5

    Do you support the CBA protocol objective of making ordinary working hours more amenable to family life?

    96.34% agreed3.66% disagreed

  • Q6

    Do you support the CBA protocol objective of making working practices less discriminatory?

    97.13% agreed2.87% disagreed

    The analysis notes that disagreement here was not a vote for discrimination but a view that current expectations are already non-discriminatory.

  • Q7

    Do you agree with the CBA protocol objective that the criminal Bar should be treated equally with the family Bar?

    98.94% agreed1.06% disagreed

  • Q8

    Overall, do you support the adoption of the CBA wellbeing protocol?

    98.18% agreed1.82% disagreed

    Such negative comment as there was focused on the likelihood of the protocol being adopted rather than on whether it was worthwhile.

On verbal aggression

One negative comment on the protocol was singled out in the analysis for a reply. It objected to paragraph 15, which states that all court users are entitled to be treated with courtesy and respect and that verbal aggression is a form of abuse which should never be justified.

The Committee reaffirmed that paragraph in its entirety and distanced itself entirely from the comment and the sentiments behind it. Verbal aggression, it observed, can very easily become intimidation and bullying; it is by no means restricted to the bench, where it is remarkably rare, and is far more prevalent in interactions between members of the Bar, particularly in emails, and particularly emails sent late at night.

The other comments were highly supportive. The analysis concludes that there is a groundswell of support among the vast majority of practitioners, and that the Committee’s focus would turn to implementing the protocol.

The full analysis

The complete published analysis, with the explanatory note and respondents’ comments for every question.

Download the analysis (PDF)

Related