For Students
The work of a criminal barrister
Prosecuting and defending, regulatory work, and the difference between the employed and self-employed Bar.
The Work of a Criminal Barrister
Solicitors vs Barristers
If someone is accused of committing a crime and finds themselves in the criminal justice system, they will come across legal professionals including barristers and solicitors.
Solicitors mainly deal with the client face-to-face, represent the client at a police station after they have been arrested, gather and collate evidence to help the defence case, and conduct litigation as the case is prepared for trial. Traditionally a solicitor would instruct a barrister to represent their client at trial, although solicitors are now often qualified to and do act for clients instead of a barrister.
Barristers mainly receive instructions from the solicitor about the client's case and then prepare to represent the client in court when they give live evidence. Criminal barristers almost exclusively work in court, either prosecuting or defending criminal trials. They specialise in oral advocacy – in arguing their client's case or presenting the case on behalf of the Crown. When not in court, they are busy preparing their next trial, having conferences with clients, and advising on the law.
Where Criminal Barristers Work
Most of a criminal barrister's working life is spent in court. Most criminal barristers are self-employed and work independently from a shared office called a ‘chambers’. A criminal barrister builds a reputation from conducting cases. They are also promoted by their chambers, and work is distributed between members of chambers by clerks.
Not all barristers are self-employed. Barristers may be employed by a firm of solicitors, or be employed in-house and work for an organisation such as the Crown Prosecution Service or the Serious Fraud Office.
Some barristers specialise in particular kinds of work within crime, such as high-level fraud, organised crime, counter-terrorism, or sexual offences, while others maintain a more general practice.
Prosecuting
Although a few individuals and corporations bring private prosecutions, the vast majority of prosecuting in England and Wales is done by the Crown (representing the State), and most of those via the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), whose independent reviewing lawyers will take the material given to them by the police or some investigating authority and assess it to determine whether there is a realistic prospect of obtaining a conviction in court.
In England and Wales, it is the Prosecution who brings the case against a defendant. It is therefore for the prosecution to prove the case (they bear the so-called ‘burden of proof’), and they must do so to a standard whereby the court – whether Judge(s) or jurors – must be satisfied so that they are sure of the defendant's guilt. No defendant is ever required to prove their innocence.
Because the Prosecution bring the case, they also take charge of the general shape and structure of the case; they will decide how it is charged and will introduce it in court.
As a prosecution barrister, you will be in charge of conducting the trial and calling the evidence in the case. The barrister will argue all legal points that arise, cross-examine the defendant to test their account, and argue the prosecution case to the jury or judge.
Defending
Most barristers begin their career being instructed for the defence, and it is likely that in your second six months of pupillage (and probably throughout the early part of your tenancy) this will constitute the overwhelming majority of your case-work. A defendant has every right to maintain their innocence until proven guilty. Defendants contest cases because they instruct their solicitors and barristers that they are not guilty and have been advised that they have a defence to the charge. The barrister will challenge the evidence called by the prosecution, cross-examine witnesses with a view to undermining the credibility and reliability of the witness, and make closing speeches trying to persuade the judge or jury that the Prosecution have not proved their case.
Some barristers become additionally qualified to conduct Direct Access work, so that potential clients can come straight to them rather than via solicitors.
Regulatory Work
Many professions, particularly those requiring special qualifications to perform and which are of particular importance to wider society (such as medicine), are subject to the oversight of regulatory bodies. These include:
- Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC)
- Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)
- Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA)
- Bar Standards Board (BSB)
If these bodies receive a complaint or need to conduct a disciplinary hearing, they may require the services of a barrister either to review their evidence or to represent one of the parties. A growing number of criminal barristers take on work of this kind in addition to more general criminal work. Because of the close proximity of this work to general crime, practitioners sometimes refer to it as ‘quasi-criminal’.
Employed Bar
Although most barristers are self-employed, around 1 in 5 work as employees of larger organisations, either retained in-house by firms of solicitors or by legal bodies such as the Serious Fraud Office (SFO), HMRC, or CPS.
There are advantages and disadvantages to this mode of working: many barristers value the prospect of a steady monthly salary and stable employment, while many others relish the independence and variety that comes with a self-employed practice.
Self-Employed Criminal Bar
Most criminal barristers are self-employed and work independently as part of a collection of other self-employed barristers known as chambers. A criminal barrister builds a reputation from conducting cases. They are also promoted by their chambers, and work is distributed between members of chambers. Barristers working from chambers help each other out and often work in practice teams. If necessary, they cover each other's cases – if a barrister becomes unavailable, another criminal barrister in chambers will often take over the conduct of the case.
Chambers have administrative staff to run barristers' diaries and collect their fees. These administrators are called clerks, and they are responsible for the smooth running of chambers: they liaise with solicitors, set the barrister's fees and ensure they are paid, and allocate work to ensure that each member of chambers has the right amount of work in their diary, and that nobody is double-booked.
- Legal 500
- Chambers and Partners
