Let there be absolutely NO doubt: the Criminal Bar Association is opposed to the proposed restrictions on the right to jury trialfundamentally
-
Election of new Vice Chair of CBA – Kama Melly KC.
-
Publication of latest Criminal Courts Statistics reveals that the Crown Court backlog has stabilised.
-
Please sign up for the free JUSTICE ‘Save our Juries’ newsletter
-
Proceedings against Rajiv Menon KC – update
-
Kalisher Trust Event – ‘Dock Brief’
-
In memoriam: Graham Henson
-
Court Summer Socials
Weather News - Scorchio!
Thank you to all of the criminal barristers who made it through last week’s extreme heat to keep the courts open. We had to put up with uncomfortable commutes, childcare crises, inappropriate clothing, broken air conditioning systems, noisy air conditioning systems and in far too many places overheated courtrooms. Likewise, it is a tribute to the dedication of jurors, court staff, dock officers and Judges that they persevered to keep cases running.
Official guidance from the Ministry of Justice states that if temperatures rise above 26°C in court buildings “it may be appropriate to close the facilities and divert those in custody to other courts or utilise remote video link facilities”.
Some courts fared worse than others last week. Hearings were abandoned or disrupted at a number of court centres, including Bristol, Nottingham and Harrow. At Bristol, it was the temperature in the cells which became dangerously high. At Harrow, the sentencing of six defendants in a high profile case had to be postponed because it was impossible to bring the courtroom temperature down. The Senior Presiding Judge, Lord Justice Green, had earlier on Friday made a welcome intervention, notifying all resident judges that they should ‘take sensible and pragmatic decisions’ and should either rise early or close if conditions were affecting the safety of court users.
The MoJ do not need reminding that our crumbling courts infrastructure is one of the major causes of delays. The settlement which the MoJ agreed with Government in February this year included £287 million “to be invested into the fabric of the court estate”. We are told that extreme weather events are the new normal. What is very clear is that future planning must take into account the need for courts to function in difficult weeks such as the one which we have just had.
For press coverage, see here:
The Law Society Gazette: Heatwave: Courts finally get permission to close
Nottinghamshire Live: Trials halted and people sent home as Nottingham court affected by heatwave
Sky News: London court abandons sentencing due to heatwave temperatures
The Telegraph: Justice delayed as courts close in heatwave and trials are stopped
New Vice Chair of CBA elected
We are delighted to announce that Kama Melly KC has been elected as the next Vice Chair of the CBA.
Kama is a longstanding member of the CBA Executive Committee and has been Chair of the CBA’s RASSO committee since 2025. She is also a former elected member of the Bar Council. Kama has been a silk since 2016 and a Bencher of Middle Temple since 2018.
Kama is a member of Park Square Chambers in Leeds, where she is Deputy Head of Chambers. She also practises from 36 Group Chambers in London.
Kama will take over as Vice Chair for a year on 1st September 2026, coinciding with current Vice Chair Andrew Thomas KC taking the Chair for a year. Kama will succeed as Chair in September 2027.
Crown Court Backlog Stabilises, contradicting MoJ predictions
Publication of the latest Criminal Courts Statistics undermines the Government’s justification for curtailing rights to trial by jury in the Courts and Tribunals Bill.
On Thursday 25th June 2026, the MoJ published the latest set of Criminal Courts Statistics, covering the period January to March 2026 (Q1). Full details can be found here.
As at 31st March 2026, the Crown Court ‘Open Caseload’ (aka the backlog) for the whole of England and Wales stood at 80,061 cases. This is a slight fall since 31st December 2025 (originally reported as 80,203, but now revised to 80,098).
This data stands in stark contrast to the Government’s predictions. In the Second Reading debate of the Courts and Tribunals Bill, our Justice Ministers told MPs that the backlog was predicted to rise to 200,000 cases by 2035 (a forecasted rate of increase of 16.5% per annum).
Likewise, the Impact Assessment which accompanied the Bill the Government predicted the backlog would increase on a “central assumption” to 100,000 cases by 2028, and 123,000 cases by Q1 2030 (a forecasted rate of increase of 12% per annum) and on a “higher demand” scenario to 135,000 by Q1 2030 and 204,000 by Q1 2035.
The latest figures show that the trend is not continuing growth, but stabilisation – indeed a slight fall for the country as a whole
Falling Receipts
Importantly while the Government’s projections accompanying the Courts and Tribunal Bill seem to be based on a relentless increase in new cases coming into the Crown Court (receipts) both on a “central” and “higher demand” basis, the latest quarterly figures point to a continued decline in receipts. Receipts fell for the third consecutive quarter, down to 29,426 in Q1 2026 from 29,569 in Q4 2025. That continues a fall in receipts seen for the whole of 2026 of 120,629, compared to 121,628 in 2025. Notably Q1 2026 was the second consecutive quarter of receipts falling below 30,000 and down markedly from the quarterly high of 31,746 in Q3 2024.
Regional Performance
The Criminal Courts Statistics also provide a breakdown region by region, and figures for each Crown Court centre. These show that in the last quarter the backlog fell in 4 out of 7 regions of England and Wales.
-
In the South East, the backlog is down 4.2% over past 6 months – from 15,6245 to 15,557 cases.
-
In the North West, the backlog is down 3.3% over the past 6 months – from 10,051 to 9,724 cases.
-
In the North East, the backlog is down 2.3% over the past 6 months – from 11,072 to 10,815 cases.
-
In Wales, the backlog is down 2.4% over the past 6 months – from 2,913 to 2,805 cases.
Some individual Crown Courts have shown impressive progress in the latest quarter. Examples include:
-
Ipswich – down 10.4%
-
Canterbury – down 9%
-
Maidstone – down 10%
-
Oxford – down 3.1%
-
Cardiff – down 6.7%
-
Sheffield – down 4.7%
-
Newcastle – down 8.3%
-
Manchester Crown Square – down 4.1%.
-
Preston – down 5.1%
-
Nottingham – down 3.1%
-
Derby – down 3.1%
What is the trend in prison data?
Another key indicator of the direction of travel is the MoJ’s Prison Statistics, which can be found here. These show that the number of prisoners on remand has also fallen by 9% in the year to 31st March 2026, comprising a 7% drop in prisoners waiting trial and 13% drop in convicted prisoners waiting sentence. The MoJ attributes this impressive fall (in part) to the increase in the number of sitting days in the Crown Court.
Why has the Crown Court backlog stabilised?
The latest statistics cover a period when initiatives have been taking place up and down the country to target problem areas of work and reduce the outstanding caseload. It also reflects the initial partial increase in annual sitting days (from 110,000 to 111,250) announced by the Deputy Prime Minister and Lord Chancellor, David Lammy, in October 2025. However, it pre-dates the impact of the total removal of the cap, which only took effect on 1st April 2026.
What about the Magistrates’ Courts backlog?
The Q1 2026 Criminal Courts Statistics also include the figures for Magistrates’ Courts, where the backlog now stands at 370,722 open cases – an increase of 5,943 cases on the quarter (an increase of 2%). Overall, the Magistrates’ Courts backlog has increased by 37,528 cases over the past 12 months (an increase of 11.3%).
What are the implications for the Courts and Tribunals Bill?
The combined effect of Clauses 1 to 7 of the Courts and Tribunals Bill would be to halve the number of cases which are tried with a jury in our Crown Courts. Around 25% of cases would be heard in the Magistrates’ Courts, with increased sentencing powers. Another 25% would be heard in Judge-alone trials in the Crown Court.
The justification for this unprecedented attack on existing rights to trial by jury is that it is necessary to deal with the ‘crisis’ caused by the backlog. In the Government’s Impact Assessment, they explain that their ambition for the legislation is: “to turn the tide on the rising open caseload so that it is on a downward trend by the end of this Parliament” [ie. summer 2029].
The past two quarters of Crown Court Statistics show that we have already turned the tide, and we are already on a downward trend. The backlog has stabilised, even before the removal of the cap on sitting days has taken effect and before the roll out of efficiency reforms recommended by Sir Brian Leveson.
The dire predictions given to MPs by the Justice Ministers in the Second Reading debate, based on untested assumptions, now have the appearance of fearmongering. Despite repeated requests from MPs, the Justice Select Committee, the CBA and Bar Council, the Government have never published the calculations which led them to make those claims. The MoJ cried ‘wolf’, but the political delays in progressing the Bill means that we now have the hard evidence which shows that the picture is not as they painted.
As the CBA has repeatedly pointed out, curtailing the right to jury trial is not the answer to reducing the backlog. For example, the independent analysis of the Institute for Government concluded that the system of judge-only trials would reduce overall completion times by only 1-2%. Meanwhile the suggestion of moving potentially tens of thousands of cases into the Magistrates Courts is complete folly at a time when the Magistrates’ Courts backlog is still rising at an alarming rate, and sitting at an all time high.
Following the publication of the figures, Justice Minister Sarah Sackman MP welcomed the progress which had been made but doubled down on the claim that legislation was required. She argued that it would take 300 years ‘to clear the backlog’ at this rate. Respectfully, we disagree with that analysis. First, the Q1 figures pre-date many of the steps which are being taken, and have been recommended, to reduce the backlog – we have not even yet seen the Government’s long-awaited response to Sir Brian Leveson’s reports.
Second, in any event no-one suggests that the backlog can or should be reduced to nil. The ‘open caseload’ figure represents the work in progress of the Crown Courts, reflecting all cases between sending and completion. There are always going to be cases in the open caseload, working their way through the system. Prior to the Covid pandemic, they stood at between a series low of 33,000 in January 2019 and 41,000 by March 2020. Realistic targets should be set, and a properly informed debate should take place.
What do the CBA say about these figures?
Responding to the figures last Thursday, we said this.
Riel Karmy-Jones KC, Chair of the CBA, said:
“It’s high time the Government ditched its ill-conceived attack on the right to trial by jury. The justification for these plans has never been there — these figures show MPs have been misled by assumptions dressed up as evidence.
“The Government announced this legislation without a shred of evidence that jury reforms were needed. It simply asserted they would cut the backlog and help victims — with nothing to back that up. For months we called on the Government to publish the data to back their claims. It finally provided an Impact Assessment, in February 2026, which stated that the Bill would help bring down the Crown Court backlog and ‘turn the tide’ so it falls by 2029. But the assessment offered no real data — only assumptions dressed up as evidence.
“The truth is juries are not the cause of the backlog, of delays to trial, or of victims withdrawing. The real cause is a decade of successive governments cutting costs and capping the number of days Crown Courts can sit — shortsighted, money-saving measures that have done long-term damage to our justice system.
“The cap has now been lifted in full, since 1 April 2026. We’re yet to see the full impact of that on the statistics. What today’s figures show is that, thanks to the hard work of our judges, criminal barristers, HMCTS staff, the CPS and defence solicitors, the measures we have pushed forward are and already taken in our courts are starting to turn the tide.
“But just as the cap on sitting days caused lasting damage, so has neglect elsewhere in the system. The Crown Court estate is literally crumbling. We can’t recruit or retain enough judges, barristers or court staff. As a result, courts can’t make full use of the extra sitting days — hundreds are closed every week, unable to hear serious cases. What’s needed now is investment, not rhetoric based on assumption.”
Andrew Thomas KC, Vice Chair of the CBA said:
“The attack on trial by jury involves an ill-conceived plan to switch thousands of serious cases from the Crown Court to the already overcrowded Magistrates’ Courts. It looks like an attempt to deliver justice on the cheap.
As the cross-party Justice Select Committee have demonstrated in their report on the Bill, these proposals will simply backfire. The Magistrates’ Courts do not have the capacity to take on tens of thousands of more serious, more complex cases. Legal Aid is not available on the same basis before the Magistrates’ Court, and thousands of people facing long sentences of imprisonment will end up representing themselves.
The backlog has never been a proper justification for the attack on jury trials. The measures which are needed to bring the backlog down are practical steps – allowing the Crown Courts to sit to maximum capacity; blitz courts to target problem areas of work; increasing the incentives to plead guilty.
When the legislation was first announced in December, Andy Burnham called on the government to pause and rethink the plans. He rightly described the jury system as a “lynchpin of a fair society”. We agree. Today’s figures show that he was right to be sceptical of the plans.”
The CBA’s full statement on the publication of the Criminal Courts Statistics can be found here.
The Bar Council’s statement is here.
Some of the media coverage can be found here:
Daily Express: David Lammy accused of ’scaremongering’ as top lawyers vent fury
The Law Society Gazette: Crown court backlog falls by a whisker as jury trial row intensifies
Please Subscribe to the ‘JUSTICE’ newsletter
On the topic of Jury Trials, JUSTICE – the legal reform charity – publishes an excellent, free weekly email newsletter, summarising the latest information concerning the Jury Trials debate. Titled the ‘Save our Juries’ newsletter, it provides the latest updates from Parliament, summaries of the past week’s press reporting and details of other developments in the debate.
You can sign up here.
Proceedings against Rajiv Menon KC
On Monday 22nd June 2026, Jeremy Johnson J handed down his decision on the potential contempt of court proceedings against Rajiv Menon KC. A copy of his ruling can be found here.
This follows the earlier Court of Appeal decision, which held that the original procedure followed was unlawful. A copy of their Judgment can be found here.
The CBA is closely following these developments. The ability of barristers to present their client’s case fearlessly is an important constitutional right. We are concerned, in particular, about aspects of the process which is being followed. Other than in cases where it is important for a Judge to act ‘there and then’ to deal with contempt in the face of the court, ordinarily allegations of contempt are referred to the Attorney General who determines whether or not proceedings are in the public interest.
Kalisher Trust – Dock Brief
In Memoriam – Graham Henson
On Friday 27th June 2026, a eulogy was held at Birmingham Crown Court for Graham Henson of No 5 Chambers, Birmingham. Graham had been a criminal barrister for almost 50 years, practising initially on the South Eastern circuit and later in the Midlands.
Harpreet Singh KC, Leader of the Midlands Circuit, said at the eulogy: “Graham Henson was unassailably brilliant and always grounded. Juries were spellbound by him. His delivery was mellifluous and his contact with his tribunal direct. He was a true artist who considered language to be the palette each barrister is lucky enough to be given.”
In a statement, No 5 Chambers said: “Graham Henson was, without doubt, one of the great characters of the Birmingham Bar. Graham was an individual with a sharp intellect and an advocate of the highest quality. He was one of the best defenders of the, apparently, entirely hopeless. He simply didn’t recognise this concept and produced results which were unimaginable at the start of the trial. He was also an utterly fearless advocate but, whatever the case, Graham dealt with opponents, and judiciary, with charm and professionalism.
He was a thoroughly decent man who cared passionately about the welfare of his clients, both lay and professional.
No5 has lost one of its great advocates – we will miss him.”
and finally, a social summer
NEW Webinar - WICL’s ’Better Workplace Conversations’ on 8th July 2026, 6pm
We often have at least one conversation with a colleague we’ve been putting off — feedback that needs sharing, a boundary that needs holding, a moment we didn’t handle as well as we’d have liked. Tough conversations don’t get easier by being avoided. They can get more difficult.
On 8 July 2026 from 6PM - 7:30PM, we’re hosting a 90-minute online session with Emily Cosgrove, an experienced coach and faciliator, to offer a practical look at three of the most challenging communication situations: delivering feedback that lands well, holding your ground without showing aggression, and staying grounded when conversations become emotionally charged.
We’re delighted to welcome Emily back; she will be familiar to long-standing WICL members from our very first mentoring evening!
We hope the session will assist all of us who work with others, being senior and junior solicitors and barristers, and clerks. You can expect real scenarios, honest reflection, and tools and techniques you can start to use straight away.
The event is open to members and non members, but for some will require a small fee.
Please do sign up on our Eventbrite to secure your space. We look forward to seeing you there!!
Crown Court Sunmer Socials
The Guildford Judges warmly invite the Bar to Summer Drinks
Thursday 2nd July from
16.30 - 20.00
Contact HHJ Harden-Frost to reserve your ticket
The Isleworth Judges invite the Bar to Summer Drinks
Thursday 9th July from 16.45 - 20.30
The Kingston Judges warmly invite the to the Bar Mess Summer Party
Thursday 16th July from 16.30 - 19.30
Yours,
Riel Karmy-Jones KC Andrew Thomas KC
Chair Vice Chair
Events
Lectures:
Our Lecture series will continue next term
Socials:
The Guildford Judges warmly invite the Bar to Summer Drinks
Thursday 2nd July from
16.30 - 20.00
Contact HHJ Harden-Frost to reserve your ticket
The Isleworth Judges invite the Bar to Summer Drinks
Thursday 9th July
16.45 - 20.30
The Kingston Judges warmly invite the to the Bar Mess Summer Party
Thursday 16th July
16.30 - 19.30
Podcasts
Episode 2: The CBA Submission to the Leveson Review of Criminal Justice
Episode 3: Should offenders be forced to attend their sentencing hearing
Episode 6: Mary Prior KC in conversation with Barbara Mills KC
Episode 7: The Secret Barrister and the Lammy Reform
Episode 8: Karl Turner MP and the Government’s proposals for Criminal Justice refrom and jury trials
Episode 9: The Courts & Tribunal Bill
Episode 10: In-conversation with Martin Shaw
Episode 11: In-conservation with Lord Andrew Edis
Further Podcasts will follow in due course.
News
Fighting Knife Crime - London:
Fighting Knife Crime London has an urgent request for funding. Further details are here.
Confidential Reporting Tool:
For Harassment & Bullying reporting:
AGFS Billing:
A resource has been drafted by the Chambers Administrator at St Paul’s Chambers. It is incredibly useful and can be accessed here
LAA Guidance:
Updated to include information on claiming for offences not listed in the AGFS banding document or LGFS table of offences
CPD Guidance & Templates:
HMCTS Updates:
Crime Programme
Scholarships
CBA Advanced Advocacy Scholarship:
Details for awards up to £2,000.00 for 2026 are available here
International Scholarships:
The CBA continue to support the Bar Council’s International programme.
Further details are available here
The Kalisher Essay Competition:
The competition carries a prize of £2,000 for the winner and £500 for the runner up. The competition is open to everyone in a pupillage specialising in criminal law.
Further details are available here
Read our Protocol here. Should your chambers wish to adopt our protocol, please contact our administrator.
Wellbeing:
To gain access to the Health and Wellbeing Portal you will require the following login credentials:
Username: Barcouncil
Password: EAP
0800 169 2041
This Programme (access to 24/7 helpline, counselling and online resources) is available to all self-employed barristers and pupils. Further Details access here
Law Care:
LawCare provides an independent and confidential service which assists members of the Law Societies of England and Wales.
Further information is available through their website
Vacancies
Castle Chambers:
No closing date
1MCB Chambers - Opportunities for Tenancy & Probationary Tenancy:
No closing date
2 KBW is Recruiting:
No closing date
Practice Manager:
5 Pump Court
Third Six Pupillage Vacancies:
Pump Court Chambers
Goldsmith Chambers Recruitment:
No closing date
KCH Garden Square Recruitment:
No closing date
Albion Chambers Recruitment:
Tenants & Third Six
No closing date
Other Events:
Criminal Pupils:
’Advocacy for Children in Conflict with the Law’ Training Course
November 2025 - June 2026
Bursaries
The CBA Bursary:
Our Bursary will launch in this year.
Discounts
Wildy & Sons Criminal Bar Discount offer for Archbold & Blackstone’s 2026 for those under 5 years call: 55% Discount
Archbold 2025: 55% discount
Further information and to order
Archbold on Proview: contact (address withheld on the website)
Banks on Sentence - 10% Discount
Legal Professional Privilege in Criminal Investigations and Proceedings - 30% Discount
Other offers:
Oxford University Press
Bloomsbury Publishing
Wildy & Sons 2024 Editions
Youth Justice Law and Practice
Sexual Offences Referencer - 30% Discount
Statistics in the Law of Evidence - 20% Discount
Member Benefits:
Please view the various discounted rewards here.
Criminal Law Week - updates (issue 24):
Key updates from this week’s issue of Criminal Law Week:
Crime and Policing Act 2026 – commencement on 29 June 2026 of various provisions of the 2026 Act, including in relation to anti-social behaviour, firearms, purported intimate image generators, public order and protest offences, confiscation, police powers and terrorism: SI 2026/689, CLW/26/24/23.
Sentences for public protection – correct approach to be taken in out of time appeals against sentences of imprisonment/detention for public protection imposed on young offenders, with commentary: R. v Davis and ors, CLW/26/24/12, CA.
Corrosive fluids – application of the guideline for an offence contrary to section 18 of the Offences against the Person Act 1861 when sentencing an offence of applying a corrosive fluid with intent contrary to section 29 of that Act: R. v Newton, CLW/26/24/10, CA.
Habeas corpus – unlawful delay in releasing 18-year-old remand prisoner sentenced to a detention and training order from a Serco-operated prison, with commentary: Gambrah v Director of HMP Thameside, CLW/26/24/14, KBD (Hill J).
Prison Rules – amendments to the Prison Rules 1999 increasing and creating new punishments available to prison governors and adjudicators for offences against discipline: SI 2026/664, CLW/26/24/25.
Commonwealth cases – a selection of cases from Commonwealth jurisdictions of potential interest to UK practitioners concerning abuse of process and fitness to plead, bad character evidence, conspiracy to commit misconduct in public office, “counter-intuitive” evidence, delays in joint trials, and legal professional privilege: CLW/26/24/17–22.
